Taking it to eXtremes

“If I were to make a prediction, I’d think there’s a good chance that it is not batteries. But capacitors.”  Karl Young, CEO of eXtreme Capacitor, Inc. started his presentation at the fifth annual Electric Aircraft Symposium with these words from Tesla Motor’s Elon Musk.  The reference to capacitors superseding batteries as an energy source for electric cars came from Musk’s address at the Cleantech Forum in San Francisco on 16 March 2011.

Young’s talk before the April 29 gathering in Santa Rosa, California detailed the double-layer supercapacitors his company produces, and what Young feels are the advantages these have over “traditional” lithium and other batteries.  He is “trying to overcome the issues of batteries,” including, according to Young, their weight, slow charge and discharge times, their short operational lifetimes (typically 500 to 3,000 cycles), and their toxicity and flammability.

Typical lithium cell construction (http://www.electricitystorage.org/ESA/technologies/)

Young contrasted that with the specifications for his eXtreme X-Cap™ “double-layer capacitor-based energy storage technology,” which can last through over one million deep cycles, essentially making it a perpetual battery.  While batteries sometimes take hours to charge, ultracaps can be charged in minutes or even seconds.  Coupled with this is a “round-trip efficiency” of over 98 percent – meaning the capacitor loses less than two percent of the energy used to recharge it.  Lead-acid batteries have a round-trip efficiency of around 50 to 70 percent, and lithium cells might approach 95 percent. 

eXtreme Cap construction (http://www.electricitystorage.org/ESA/technologies/)

eXtreme’s high power-to-weight ratio, 250 Watt-hours per kilogram compared to lithium cells’ 128 watt-hours per kilogram, overcomes one objection to capacitors as energy storage devices.  Most capacitors have markedly higher power outputs over short times than batteries can deliver, but cannot produce that power for extended periods.  This makes capacitors wonderful for sprints, but not for marathons, but usually heavier as they extend their energy capacity.  X-Caps are also safer, not being made from toxic or flammable materials, according to Young. 

He also noted a cost goal of $300 per kilowatt-hour, making them half to one-fifth the cost of current lithium batteries.  This would be a great deal less expensive than the $1,000 per kilowatt-hour projected last year by Carnegie Mellon University for the Chevrolet Volt battery pack – a price General Motors said was at least $200 over its estimates.

Activated carbon, used in currently available supercapacitors, but Carbon nanotubes are the big thing in making supercapacitors into ultra and eXtreme capacitors.  Massachusetts Institute of Technology researchers use a forest of carbon filaments as a way to gain additional area for electrodes, and some battery and capacitor manufacturers use a carbon nanontube paper, looking a bit random and loosely packed, to gain additional surface area.  eXtreme has developed a spinning method, which looks much like a textile manufacturing technique used in spinning wheels to pull individual strands of fleece together to make woolen yarn.  In this instance, carbon nanotubes are pulled together into long, three-dimensional structures that are light, strong, and provide a high “packing factor,” and therefore a high wetting area against which the battery’s electrolyte can react. 

Electric Eagle air taxi

This lightweight, high-energy package seems ideal for aircraft use, and Young closed his presentation with a concept air taxi, the Electric Eagle, looking much like the Beechcraft Starship of the 1970’s, but a proprietary design of eXtreme Capacitor, Inc.  A 300 mph, 500-mile range aircraft, the Eagle would be a great demonstrator for the energy storage devices we trust can become a soon-realized reality.

{ 6 comments… add one }

  • Dick 06/09/2011, 6:41 pm

    I saw this NASA capacitor research at Oshkosh several years ago and was recentlly wondering whatever became of it. Thanks for the update.
    My son is confined to an electric wheelchair and uses a ventilator, both of which require batteries. Could we ever use these capacitors.
    I am looking forward to great advances in this technology.

    Thank You,
    Dick

  • Bill white 06/09/2011, 7:19 pm

    Now we’re getting somewhere!! Patents shouldn’t be able to be bought.

  • Greg Hunt 06/10/2011, 9:42 am

    I am wondering about an alternative power source for an experimental aircraft design I’m working on of about 600 lbs. of carbon fiber, weight includes engine of 120 lbs. and 120 horse. Is there a comparable weight to power ratio using capacitor’s at this time that I could convert to including motor and still be within 120 lbs. so as to not have to change my C.G much or add ballast?

  • C. Jeff Dyrek 06/10/2011, 9:49 am

    These new nano tube capacitors are a fantastic idea. But the idea of using nano tubes as the capacitors also gives the idea that the power source, the nano tubes, could also be used as structural components of the aircraft. Nano-tubes are extremely strong forms of carbon fiber, as we know it, but with a specific molecular construction that makes them even stronger. If we can combine the entire structure of the aircraft for a dual purpose of structural strength and a storage for the power source at the same time, we wouldn’t even need batteries or fuel tanks at all. Just some thoughts, C. Jeff Dyrek, Webmaster, Explorer.

  • Karl Young 06/26/2011, 12:07 am

    Multi-wall carbon nanotubes (MWNT) are less expensive to produce and easier to spin than single-wall carbonanotubes. We are hoping to produce MWNT filaments and threads for weavers to produce uni-directional and woven fabrics for the aviation and aerospace industries. MWNTs are as strong as the best carbon fibers, and 3-4 times tougher (not to mention electrically more conductive) than carbon fibers. To estimate weight density of MWNTs, 1 gram/cc would be a rough number to start with, not including any resin matrix. Different yarn densities, weave patterns and resin ratio would yield different composites laminate densities. It won’t be too far off from a carbon fiber/epoxy’s laminate weight density, however.

  • Karl Young 06/26/2011, 1:09 am

    We’re seeing about 7 kW/kg (4.2 ehp/lb) specific-power from carbon nanotube (CNT) supercapacitors using non-aligned CNTs. We anticipate greater values from our X-Caps, once we get the cell design more optimized, since we use aligned CNTs in our electrodes. Electrons travel down the CNT surface at extremely fast speeds (much faster than in copper), so the more aligned the CNTs, the lower the resistance. We try to align our CNTs as much as possible to maximize power density. We hope to achieve 12+ kW/kg (7.2 ehp/lb). This means, 17 lbs of our X-Cap should be able to provide enough electric power for a 120 hp electric motor, but will need about 1600 lbs of X-Caps for a 2-hr flight (180 kWh) at full power. This is not practical for electric airplanes of this particular design, so we will try to triple our X-Cap specific-energy in the years to come. However, if only 80 hp is used during cruise, then the X-Cap weight can be reduced to 1,100 lbs for a 2-hr flight; still too heavy, in my opinion. Fortunately, cars only need about 40 kWh for a 200 mile trip; which is about 350 lbs of X-Caps.

Leave a Comment